Society is obsessed with masculinity, and constantly discussing how it’s ‘in crisis’. But how helpful are these debates? Can masculinity be reshaped as ‘positive’ or ‘healthy’ – and should that be our focus? In a challenging new paper – ‘Positive humanity, when? Is masculinity worth saving?’ – Dr Finn Mackay argues that policy aimed at saving men and alleviating their suffering does not address men’s humanity, but is erroneously focused on ‘saving’ masculinity. Instead, Finn believes we should aspire to be positive, healthy people and equal human beings, without needing to have our identities as men reinforced. Rather than recycling tired biological essentialism, Finn concludes “it is time for men and women to start acting like we really believe we are not separate spheres, but on the same planet, with the same needs for love and care, the same need to matter to our communities, the same need for life”. Finn advocates for a radical feminist analysis, arguing that it offers positive solutions to the problems all of us face – including men and boys.
The episode discusses Finn’s 2021 book ‘Female Masculinities and the Gender Wars: The Politics of Sex’. Based on research they conducted on lesbian and queer masculinities in the UK, they explore the challenges and obstacles facing those who do not fit into strict boxes of sex and gender. This is particularly topical given the recent ruling by the UK Supreme Court that the terms “woman” and “sex” in the Equality Act 2010 refer only to “biological women” and “biological sex”. Decrying the widespread scapegoating and demonising of trans people, Finn argues they have become easy targets for regressive gender conservatism.
Finn ends by talking movingly about their personal journey from growing up in rural Scotland, to living at women’s peace camps outside military bases, and the impact that feminism – especially radical feminism – has had on their life.
